Blog powered by TypePad
Member since 02/2010

You can find 1000+ of my kitchen-tested recipes using the Recipes tab, watch nearly 100 of my Kitchen Encounters/WHVL-TV segments using the TV Videos tab, join the discussion about all of my creations using the Facebook tab, or Email your questions and comments directly to me--none go unanswered. Have fun!


~ Yankee Pot Roast: Simple, Sensible, Scrumptious (w/Mushroom Gravy & Roasted Carrots & Potatoes)~

6a0120a8551282970b017c32faf857970bThe power of pot roast is very underestimated.  Why?  Read on.  While I was growing up, I remember eating pot roast on many a Sunday after church.  I'm here to tell you:  I did not like getting up early and going to church on Sunday mornings -- at all. (For the record, I still don't, and, guess what? Praying can be done on your own time, anywhere, at any time of day.  For example: Today, I'm going to be praying over this pot roast for my family, friends, Facebook friends and KE readers to remain safe during Hurricane Sandy tonight and tomorrow.)  But, on the Sundays that my mom popped a beef roast into the oven before we left for church, knowing this meal would be on the table when we arrived home made it worth the trip.  This is very appropriate since pot roast is an American dish born out of the desire for religious freedom.

What is the difference between pot roast and roast beef?

In my mom's kitchen, what we ate for Sunday dinner was (and still is) erroniously referred to as "roast beef".  Because she sears a large chuck roast on the outside, then cooks it, covered, in some liquid for a period of about 3 hours (when it emerges fall-apart tender), it is culinarily and technically:  Pot roast.  This moist-heat cooking method, which can be done in the oven or on the stovetop, is known as braising.  It is usually reserved for larger, tougher cuts of beef, like chuck.  

Roast beef, which is cooked uncovered (using the dry-heat cooking method known as roasting), emerges from the oven with a soft but firm, need-to-be-sliced texture.  This comes from using tenderer cuts of beef from the back of the animal, like:  sirloin, tenderloin and top sirloin. 

511px-BeefCutChuck.svgWhy is it sometimes called: "Yankee" pot roast?

This dates back to colonial New England. When the Pilgims arrived in America from the British Isles (the land of the boiled potato), they brought with them their religious convictions, which demanded a lifestysle of extreme plainness, simplicity and frugality, which transcended to their dinner tables. What they became infamous for eating was referred to as "the boiled dinner".  It was nothing more than a soupy mixture of a tough cut of beef or corned beef, root vegetables and sometimes cabbage, all boiled together in one big pot, until nothing more than a spoon was needed to eat it.  Sound good?  It was not. Thankfully, the New England Boiled Dinner has evolved over two centuries into what, nowadays, is quite a delicious meal.

Savvy Yankee cooks (the term used to describe the descendants of the original settlers to New England), who weren't hell-bent on depriving themselves of all of lifes foodie pleasures, began browning their own lesser cuts of beef in animal fat, seasoning it with salt and herbs, and, adding similar root vegetables to the pot (only closer to the end of the cooking process to ensure the veggies maintained texture).  The highly-seasoned liquid remaining in the pot was thickened with a bit of flour and poured over the top of the meal at the end.  Yankee Pot Roast was born.

It's time to sear the beef.

IMG_4155A bit about searing:  When it comes to making a pot roast, in my kitchen, there is no debate about searing the beef.  Do it.  Period.  Admittedly, it is not my favorite part of the process, but, what you gain in beautiful color, which translates to wonderful flavor, is well worth a few minutes of extra effort (about 15 minutes) + a little spatter and mess.

For the beef:  My first choice is a:

4-5  pound chuck roast, trimmed all all excess fat and tied

IMG_4161~ Step 1.  Generously sprinkle the top of the roast with:

Wondra Quick-Mixing Flour for Sauce and Gravy, plus additional flour for coating the second side of the roast

freshly ground sea salt and peppercorn blend, plus additional sea salt and peppercorn blend

Allow the flour-topped roast to rest, about 5 minutes, to allow flour time to absorb moisture from the meat.

~ Step 2.  In an 8-quart, enameled cast-iron Dutch oven, heat:

6  tablespoons of olive oil

over medium-high heat.

IMG_4171 IMG_4165~ Step 3. Place the roast, floured side down into the pot.  Immediately season the top with additional flour, salt & pepper.

~ Step 4.  Sear the roast, turning only once until golden brown on both sides, about 4-4 1/2 minutes per side.

IMG_4194 IMG_4180                                          ~ Step 5. Turn  roast on its side and continue to sear it, turning it about every 1-1 1/2 minutes, using a spatula to hold it upright if necessary, until it is browned on all remaining sides.

~ Step 6.  Turn the heat off and transfer the roast to a plate and set aside.

It's time to get the pot roast and the gravy ready for the oven -- but first, we must talk about the roasted vegetables.

IMG_4266Three things about my recipe:  1) Most present day versions for pot roast add tomatoes, canned tomatoes or tomato paste to the pot. My recipe does not.  Why?  Prior to 1814, tomatoes, while they were available, because of the color red, were superstitiously considered evil and poisionous, meaning:  Our forefathers would not have been cooking pot roast with "anything tomato".  They would have used a bit of vinegar or wine as their acid.  So, from that standpoint, my recipe is authentic.  2)  Most authentic versions for pot roast do not include mushrooms.  My recipe does.  Why?  Mushrooms were available, but, like the tomato, no one at the time, besides the French and Eastern Europeans were using mushrooms as an ingredient. Culinarily, anyone who had never been influenced by French or Eastern European cuisine, would never have included mushrooms in their pot roast.  So, from that standpoint, my recipe is semi-authentic.  3)  Most versions for pot roast add root vegetables (of some sort) to the pot and cook the entire meal all at once.  My recipe does not. Why?  Because I don't have too, and, besides that, vegetables that have been roasted separately are so far superior to those cooked in the pot, you don't want to go there with me.  So, from that standpoint, my recipe is not authentic, but it's my recipe.  Enjoy your dinner.

IMG_4195For the pot roast and mushroom gravy:

1/2  cup port wine or red wine, for deglazing the pot after the beef has been seared

1  pound crimini or white button mushroom caps, chopped

12  ounces  yellow or sweet onion, chopped

1/2  teaspoon garlic powder

1/2  teaspoon dried thyme leaves

freshly ground sea salt and peppercorn blend

4-5  pound chuck roast, seasoned and seared as directed above

4  cups beef broth

2  whole bay leaves

IMG_4209 IMG_4202~ Step 1. Over medium-high heat, reheat the oil and browned drippings in the the bottom of the pot.  Add the port wine.  Using a nonstick spatula, deglaze the pan by loosening the browned bits and residue from the bottom of the pot.

IMG_4224 IMG_4215                                     ~ Step 2.  Add the mushrooms and onions. Season with the garlic powder, dried thyme leaves and a sprinkling of salt and pepper.  Adjust heat to saute, stirring frequently, until mushrooms have lost about half of their moisture and onions are soft and translucent, about 5-6 minutes.

IMG_4232~ Step 3.  Return the seared beef roast to the pot, along with any red juices it exuded, to the pot.

Note:  If you have seared the beef correctly, there will be less than a tablespoon or two of juices.  You can thank me later.

Add the beef broth and the bay leaves.  The roast should be covered about half way.  Put the lid on the pot.  The hard work is over.

~ Step 4.  Place the pot on the center rack of preheated 325 oven for 4-5 hours, meaning:  about 4 hours for a 4-pound roast, or, about 5 hours for a 5-pound roast.  In the meantime:

It's time to prep and roast my E-Z carrots and potatoes.

IMG_4247Spray each of two 13" x 9" x 2" casseroles with no-stick cooking spray.  

To each casserole, add:

1/4  cup olive oil

1/2  cup diced yellow or sweet onion

1  teaspoon caraway seed

1  teaspoon sea salt

1  teaspoon black pepper

IMG_4251To one casserole add:

2  pounds carrots that have been peeled and sliced into 1 1/2"-2" lengths.

To the other casserole add:

2  pounds unpeeled small, new red potatoes, that have been cut into halves or quarters.

Toss the ingredients in each casserole until they are evenly coated in olive oil and spices.

When the pot roast comes out of the oven, place it back on the stovetop and increase the oven temperature to 400 degrees. Place both casseroles (of carrots and potaotes) in the oven and roast, uncovered, for 1 hour, stopping to toss with a spoon about every 15 minutes, until:

IMG_4273The carrots are cooked through and caramelizing , and...







... the potatoes are tender, blistered and lightly browned!

Remove both casseroles from the oven and set aside.






It's almost time to eat.

IMG_4308~ Step 1.  Once you've removed the pot roast from the oven, uncover it and take a look.  If it looks anything like this, put the lid back on the pot, set it aside, let it rest in the braising liquid (gravy) for about 60 more minutes, and, proceed with putting the carrots and potatoes into the oven.

~ Step 2.  After 60 minutes, remove the roast from the pot.  Place it on a serving platter and surround it with the lovely roasted vegetables.  Briefly reheat the mushroom gravy, slice and serve the roast with gravy ladled on top of each portion:

6a0120a8551282970b017c32f96bd2970bYankee Pot Roast:  Simple, Sensible, Scrumptious (w/Mushroom Gravy & Roasted Carrots & Potatoes:  Recipe yields 6 servings.

Special Equipment List: 8-quart enameled cast-iron Dutch oven;  large nonstick spatula;  cutting board; chef's knife; 2, 13" x 9" x 2" casserole dishes; aluminum foil; ladle

IMG_4188Cook's Note:  Because you took the extra time in the very beginning to flour, season and sear your roast, all of that flour has convieniently thickened your gravy for you.  I told you that you could thank me later.  

PS.  Try to resist the urge to process or puree your gravy.  Our forefathers didn't do that to their pot roast either.

"We are all in this food world together." ~ Melanie Preschutti

(Recipe, Commentary and Photos courtesy of Melanie's Kitchen/Copyright 2012)


Pam! This is music to my ears! Hope to hear for you again soon! ~ Mel.

The pot roast was a hit! My husband said it was one my top ten meals ever. He especially loved the roasted carrots. Thank you for the recipe!!

Pam! Fifteen chuck roasts? MY SWEET LORD... that is a lot of meat. This is an awesome recipe and I just know your are going to enjoy it. Thanks for commenting on KE and let me know how your pot roast turns out!!!

We just purchased a half of a beef and I was wondering what to do with the 15 Chuck Roasts we received. I will be trying this recipe on Sunday. Thanks for the step by step instructions!

Scotty! Sounds to me like you just found a nice piece of Yankee... ~Luv, Mel.

I have so much difficulty finding a nice piece of Yankee . . .

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment